Tue, 4th August 2009
Aminopyralid – Contaminated Manure Again
I can hardly believe it but it’s true. They’re allowing the use of aminopyralid herbicide again. This is stupidity of the first order. I mean, if there is to be a stupidity competition in the 2012 Olympics, we’re going to win. No question.
This awful persistent herbicide was taken off the market when those clever people (yes that’s sarcasm) at DEFRA finally got it through their extremely thick armour plated skulls to their peanut brains that thousands of gardeners were suffering from the contaminated manure problem.
Even though they took it off the market, the problem is going to be around until 2013 and we’re not going to be able to trust the most natural fertiliser we have. So now they’ve decided to let it out again.
Well whoopee, lets all rejoice that the our government has shown itself to be so careful of the environment and the interests of organic (and non-organic) gardeners. If I sound annoyed, it’s because I am.
Anyway, we can try to do something about it. John Shobbrook of Black Horse Allotments Association has kindly put a petition online for Gordon Brown
Please take a minute to vote – that’s all it will take you.
Ban Aminopyralid – Click Here
More Information on Aminopyralid
From the petition:
A hormone weed killer (Aminopyralid) used on grassland was taken up by grazing animals and remained in manure which, when applied to the land, caused the failure of a wide range of crops including beans, peas, potatoes and tomatoes, soft fruits and flowers. Aminopyralid attaches itself to organic matter and the length of time it takes to beak down completely is as yet unknown. The potential for contamination by aminopyralid and clopyralid is causing growers to lose confidence in peat free composts. Due to the occurrence of patches of contamination in organic matter it is extremely difficult if not impossible to ensure an uncontaminated end product. A receiver of contaminated material is landed with a problem of disposing of toxic waste. After widespread protests it was withdrawn in August 2008 but an application has been made for its reinstatement. We believe that, even taking into account improved stewardship, the use of this chemical cannot be adequately controlled
From this web site:
Testing For Aminopyralid Contaminated Manure
My original post on the subject: Aminopyralid Herbicide Residue in Manure Killing Crops
Then the update at Contaminated Manure Aminopyralid Update
Next the good news: Aminopyralid Suspended Official
Finally: What to do if you have Aminopyralid Contaminated Manure
Filed under Allotment Diary by

Comments on Aminopyralid – Contaminated Manure Again »
tracy @ 11:25 am
unbelievable. I’ve signed the petition
Neil @ 3:05 pm
Signed
Sue @ 8:43 am
Signed!
I sufferd last year and probabaly have 2 years worth in my compost heap so decided to buy growbags for teh tomatoes….guess what- yep they are affected too. Shall I give up growing toms til 2013 or beyond?!
Unless the supermarkets don’t want it we are just powerless in this country!
frank layton @ 6:59 pm
Just another example of inadequate , inept , and downright stupid management by politicians . At the salaries they get (I did not say earn) they should pay heed to those in the know , and have experience – which they plainly do not have. They never listen to their constituents , except at elections , and even then they forget all about that as soon as they enter Parliament . Tin pot gods who are overpaid and incompetent.
John @ 7:06 pm
Easy Frank, watch your blood pressure! Mind you, I’m not disagreeing with you
Contaminated manure: the backwash | Organic Gardening, Grow Seeds, Trees, Herbs, Plants @ 8:32 pm
[...] many gardeners and allotmenteers are horrified at the news: allotmenteer and author John Harrison calls the move “stupidity of the highest order”. John Shobbrook has set up a electronic [...]
Darren @ 1:16 am
I,m with you all,this needs stopping!
sheila grosvenor @ 10:40 am
Cant beleive they can make such cock-up’s,It’s like knocking on wood, We are trying to make everything more healthy for ourselves and as usual someone has to sabotage it. I have never bought manure always having easy access to it from our own horses, but I suppose that could also be contaminated couldnt it? I will now think twice about using peat-free compost in the future.
Andy Cairns @ 7:47 pm
This Government is utterly useless in all it does.
The sad fact is I flipping well voted for them.
Idiots.